From 1995’s Clueless to I Love You, Man, out this Friday, Paul Rudd has been one of the cutest actors in Hollywood. Whether clean shaven or bushy-bearded, he’s a funny, charming guy. So it took some effort to find a look that didn’t flatter and—well, let’s just say we’re glad he never got a role on Deadwood. This stylized goatee from 1999 might even be worse than the soul patch he wore to the Object Of My Affection premiere a year earlier. Judge for yourself in the gallery below.
[Photo: Getty Images]