Did American Idol find this year’s Bikini Girl Katrina Darrell? Stormi Henley, 2009′s Miss Teen USA, split the judges with her rendition of “Father Can You Hear Me” last night. Steven Tyler loved it, praising her “beautiful, tight, squeaky little voice” while Jennifer Lopez said she was “gorgeous” but the voice “wasn’t strong enough” for her. When Randy Jackson joined Tyler to send Stormi to Hollywood, J. Lo lashed out. “Seriously you two? Seriously?” said yelled over their laughter. “That might be the smallest voice we’ve ever heard in five cities.” We’re on the fence ourselves—it wasn’t a dealbreaker or a dealmaker. Where do you stand on the drama?
View Photo Gallery