Yesterday marked the 10th anniversary of the theatrical release of Love Actually and we’ve been arguing about which story line was the best. To help us decide, we asked a few of the cast members to weigh in. So who is a fan of Billy Mack and Joe? The Walking Dead’s Andrew Lincoln prefers Mack’s story line to his own. And what of Harry and Karen’s dramatic story line? Elisha Cuthbert weighs in. “I would have to say Emma Thompson,” Cuthbert tells VH1. “I just… I balled my eyes out.”
But even the film’s stars haven’t swayed us from our own favorites. (Me? I’m stuck in a Juliet, Peter and Mark love triangle; Emily? She’s a diehard Sarah, Karl and Michael fan.) So we turn it over to you to pick your favorite story line. Click through the gallery above to see what we and the stars had to say and then sound off below.