Bret is down to his fabulous five and he's getting serious about finding the right girl. He calls on three of his super fans to come in and interrogate the ladies. The fans are brutal as they question each girl one by one. The fans choose the girl they think is best for Bret to go on a solo date that will change her life forever. While they are out, the fans continue to grill the other four girls. Things in the house get tense as the fans confess which two girls they think are the worst for Bret. More than one of the girls begin to crack under the pressure of the judgment by the fans and one considers leaving the house. Bret and his date come home with a shocking surprise and he joins his superfans to discuss which girl's tour is going to end tonight.