Bret wants a woman with a creative side, so he gives the remaining 10 women a music challenge. In teams of 2, the girls write lyrics to one of Bret's tracks then perform their song on stage in front of Bret, Big John and a special guest judge. The winners get dates with Bret. After the first date a full-blown party breaks out at the mansion and a few of the girls tempt Bret with some scandalous moves. Upset by the antics, one of the other girls considers going home. The next day Bret goes on a horseback riding date and finds a deeper connection with a soft-spoken girl. Struggling between his love of partying and his desire to find a real relationship, Bret must pick two more women to send home broken-hearted.