VH1.com
Search
Go

> FEEDBACK
Did you see this show?
Is our review correct?
Seen the artist elsewhere?
Tell us what you think.

Click here to post your opinions and see what
others are saying.

Guns N' Roses
Beck
David Bowie
Reading Festival
Coldplay
Sno Core Tour
Gorillaz
Craig David
Air
David Bowie Tribute
Turin Brakes
Nick Cave
Evan Dando
The Dave Matthews Band
The Doves
Bob Dylan
Dylan 60th B'day Bash
Peter Frampton
Godspeed You Black Emperor!
Gorky's Zygotic Mynci
Guided by Voices
Billy Idol
Janet Jackson
Jerry Lee Lewis/Little Richard
Jingle Ball
Lynyrd Skynyrd
Mark Knopfler
Matchbox Twenty and Everclear
Peaches
Tom Petty/Jackson Browne
Phish
Radiohead
Sigur Ros
Roxy Music Tribute
Ron Sexsmith
Slipknot
Spiritualized
Tool
Tricky
U2
Rufus Wainwright


Godspeed You Black Emperor!
Maxwell's, Hoboken, N.J.
December 8, 2000
By C. Bottomley


Talk about power games. Having made their audience listen to a few White Panthers argue the finer points of revolutionary theory as a warmup, the nine-member Montreal music "collective" Godspeed You Black Emperor! crowd onstage and ask everyone to sit down on the club's hard floor so those standing in the back can see. "Ordinarily we do not condone any form of passivity," says one of Godspeed's two percussionists. "But I think we have to do this."

So it's impossible to divorce GYBE!'s requiem for the postmodern dream from the feeling of aching joints and general stiffness. It would be nice to say that sitting buttock-to-buttock with humanity led to a spontaneous love-in, but anguish is GYBE!'s real stock-in-flogging. Their music even emulates the throb and blinding flashes of something slowly (very slowly) bleeding to death - preferably white capitalist Amerikkka over the period of a few centuries. The typical GYBE! "movement" starts with a soft violin melody, embellished with a cello, followed by the other seven crashing in with their guitars and drums ad infinitum.

It's an awesome sound, and on record, intermingled with doomy-sounding Indians and supermarket PA announcements, it's possible to imagine GYBE!'s cinematic sweep as the aural equivalent of an Oliver Stone film, atonally fiddling while Washington burns and Tommy Lee Jones weeps. However, the on-the-road version of the mysterious group leaves the field recordings at home and settles instead for fiddling quite softly then VERY LOUDLY and then getting oh so quiet again. Ten times. No one even announces, "Here's a rave from the grave we like to call 'Cancer Towers on the Holy Road Hi-Way.'"

The repetition was beginning to make our stoned Panther pals sound downright articulate. "Tenth Emperor" Jem Cohen tried to fatten up the starving ideas with filmstrips projected on a sheet behind the band - which admittedly looked as uncomfortable on the boxcar-size stage as we did in the crowd. But after a few too many fluttering black-and-white American flags, my head was starting to feel like Kevin Costner. Were GYBE! out to get me? My feet, alas, felt nothing at all and could not answer.

   

> BACK TO THE REVIEWS

 
 
 
ShopVH1
A VH1 Shop Exclusive!