Shows Um, We’re Going To Need To See That Again: Did Keeper David Seriously Turn Down Natalie? "The more she keeps me, the more I'm going to want to stay, the harder it's going to get to leave. I might as well just leave now." by Sarah Michel 8/11/2016 Embedded from media.mtvnservices.com. </noscript> </div> When things started to get more little more real between Natalie and keeper David, David started to get cold feet. At the elimination ceremony, Natalie admits that she does have a connection with David, but leaves the ball in his court on whether or not he wants to stay. When faced with the option, David realizes just how deep his commitment issues run. In an effort to protect his own heart, he decides it’s best to exit off the island now before he gets hurt later. He could’ve gave love a little bit more of a shot. After all, he already put himself out there, literally. Don’t miss an all new Dating Naked, next Wednesday at 9/8c! Sarah Michel professional television watcher and a hopeless romantic living in Brooklyn; you see where my dilemma lies. IG: _iparker_ @_iparker_