Vote For The Top 5 Jason Newsted Era Metallica Albums

The TMS Top 5 is an institution on That Metal Show. Each week fans tune in to see Eddie, Jim and Don weigh-in and argue about such important subjects as The Top 5 Black Sabbath Riffs and The Top 5 Iron Maiden Albums. This season we’re moving the debate online. Each week we’ll be posting a new topic and the boys picks and then we’ll let the fans vote to decide which choices come out on top.

This week in honor of the season 12 premiere episode guest we’re asking you to vote for your favorite Jason Newsted Era Metallica Albums. From his full-length debut on 1988’s …And Justice For All (and yes we know his recorded debut was on The $5.98 E.P.: Garage Days Re-Revisited EP, but that’s an EP, not an album) through their self-titled commercial breakthrough and up through the controversial S&M album, Jason laid down the bass on some of the band’s most well known and best-loved songs.

Check out Eddie, Jim and Don's picks and then you can vote for your favorites albums below.  You can vote as many times for as many different albums as you like and see where they rate.  Don't forget to check back every week for more TMS Top 5 countdowns and watch That Metal Show on VH1 Classic every Saturday night at 11/10C!

Eddie Trunk

1. Metallica (The Black Album)

2. And Justice For All

3. Load

4. Garage Inc.

5. ReLoad

Jim Florentine

1. And Justice For All

2. Load

3. Metallica (The Black Album)

4. Garage Inc.

5. ReLoad

Don Jamiseon

1. Metallica (The Black Album)

2. And Justice For All

3. Load

4. Garage Inc.

5. Live Sh*t: Binge & Purge