Big Morning Buzz Live Discovers Which Ex-Boy Bander Ruled Its Correspondent’s Teenage Heart

Boy band veterans Jordan Knight and Nick Carter stopped by Big Morning Buzz Live today, joining host Nick Lachey in a triad of hotness. While the three stars waxed about their former pop groups, correspondent Ellie Lee traveled back to her teenage days to see which of them she had the biggest crush on.

In the clip above, Lee reads pages from her diary and drops clues about which singer won her heart in each entry. The guys then guess which of them she swooned over. Watch the video and play along to see if you know the former boy banders better than they know themselves!

Don’t forget to watch Big Morning Buzz Live each weekday morning at 9/8C, only on VH1.