The CW

Help Us Rank the Hunkiest Movie and TV Heartthrobs from the 2000s

How dare you forget about your first BF.

We’ll always have a special place in our hearts for the leading men responsible for first making us feel those things called hormones. It seems like just yesterday we had pics of Shane West in our lockers and posters of Josh Hartnett in our rooms to semi-make out with every night. No? Was that just me? Anyway, staple ’00s hottie Chad Michael Murray turns 34 today, which not only makes me feel old AF, but gives us some time to reflect on the original baes that still make you feel all sorts of excited.

Pizza is bae. And yes, I still say bae.