The Ultimate Teen Wolf Test: Who Is The Hottest Guy Of Them All?

Teen Wolf returns to MTV tonight at 10/9 C for its third season of thrills, chills and men boldly refusing to wear shirts. We salute these fine, brave men who transform themselves from Hollywood actors to brooding characters (often without shirts). However, we have to ask, are we more attracted to the actors on Teen Wolf or the characters that they play on Teen Wolf?

To put it bluntly: Who’s hotter? The actor or the character?

If you’re shaking your head while reading this and saying to your screen, “No. There’s no difference whatsoever. They’re the same person,” then you are wrong. Not only are you wrong, but you have little to no respect for the acting profession. These men metamorphose into completely different people when the camera rolls. THEY BECOME COMPLETELY DIFFERENT PEOPLE.

Alright? Alright.

Tyler Posey as Scott McCall OR Tyler Posey as Tyler Posey?

Sure, Tyler Posey takes off his shirt a lot on Teen Wolf, but is Tyler Posey even hotter when he’s fully clothed (and bearded)?

Who’s Hotter?

[Photo Credit: Getty Images & MTV]

Tyler Hoechlin as Derek Hale OR Tyler Hoechlin as Tyler Hoechlin?

Yes, Derek Hale doesn’t wear too many shirts and that’s a plus, but in real life Tyler Hochelin looks like he gets a little more sun.

Who’s Hotter?

[Photo Credit: Getty Images & MTV]

Colton Haynes as Jackson Whittemore OR Colton Haynes as Colton Haynes?

Look, it all comes down to if you can stand to live in a steamy shower forever with Jackson Whittemore or do you want to be with a man who wears clothing (that you can actually rip off)?

Who’s Hotter?

[Photo Credit: Splash News & MTV]

Dylan O’Brien as Stiles Stilinski OR Dylan O’Brien as Dylan O’Brien?

To my knowledge, we’ve never seen a shirtless Stiles, but he is darling. Is Dylan O’Brien even more darling in real life???

Who’s Hotter?

[Photo Credit: Getty Images & MTV]

Daniel Sharman as Isaac Lahey OR Daniel Sharman as Daniel Sharman?

New wolf in town Isaac sure can smolder, but his alter ego, Daniel Sharman, has a British accent. A BRITISH ACCENT.

Who’s Hotter?

(I’d like to add that it’s very sad there are no shirtless photos of Daniel Sharman from Teen Wolf, because HOLLER AT ME BOY:

[Photo Credit: Getty Images, MTV, Relativity Media]

Finally, which is the hottest actor–period–on Teen Wolf?

You can only choose one.

Who’s The Hottest Actor On Teen Wolf?

Teen Wolf is back on MTV tonight at 10/9 C.

[Photo Credit: MTV]