After the last elimination, New York tells her final 2 men to pack their bags because they're goin' to Playa Car, Mexico for an exotic getaway! Mexico is beautiful but things quickly get ugly when the guys threaten to kill each other and must be separated until the final elimination. But New York doesn't let a little violence ruin her good time. She throws caution, and her fake eyelashes to the wind and spends romantic time with each guy - from yacht trips and fancy dinners, to swimming with dolphins and making out on the beach. Back in Hollywood, New York makes the most difficult decision of her life and chooses the man of her dreams. But does he feel the same way about her?